The Nazarene Sect
by Avram Yehoshua
(Endnotes in parentheses)
The word that the
Turtle(1) uses in referring to Paul’s religious association, while Paul
is standing trial before Felix, is commonly translated as ‘sect.’ It’s
written that Paul was ‘a ringleader of the sect of the Nazarenes’ (Acts
The word ‘sect’ in
Greek is hay-ray-see-ohs, and is used six times in Acts and always refers
to a sect (of the Sadducees, 5:17; of the Pharisees who believe in Yeshua,
15:5; our verse in 24:5; 24:14 where Paul calls it such; 26:5 where Paul
again uses it, and 28:22 where the Jews in Rome ask Paul about ‘this sect’).
In half of the places,
5:17; 15:5; and 26:5, the word can and does stand on it’s own merit, as ‘sect’.
Wesley Perschbacher tells us that the Greek word means, ‘strictly a choice
or option; hence, a sect’ or a ‘faction’.(2) Timothy Friberg also says
that and adds,
‘a separatist group
characterized by loyalty to a certain school of thought and practice’,
a ‘sect, party, school’, and lists Acts 5:17 as such.(3)
But for the three
places of Acts 24:5, 24:14 and 28:22, we think it best translated as a ‘heretical
sect’, and not just ‘a sect.’ Why? Because in these three places, ‘the
sect of the Nazarenes’ is being disparaged and should read, the ‘heretical
sect’ of the Nazarenes. In Acts 24:5, the Turtle is not wanting to lend
any validity or credence to the Nazarenes, and so he wouldn’t imply that
they were an entity that was valid. He speaks of Paul belonging to the
Nazarenes, but says that Paul stirs ‘up trouble among the Jews all throughout
the world’, and that ‘he even tried to desecrate the Temple’ (24:6). The
implication is that this sect is not righteous or valid and hence, the
Turtle was saying it was a heretical sect, thereby casting a dark shadow
over Paul and his activities.
Paul, in defending
himself, would repeat the Turtle’s implication, calling it a heretical
sect also: ‘But this I admit to you, that according to the Way which they
call a heretical sect,’ (Acts 24:14). And when Paul comes to Rome, the
Jews that come to him would think of it as a heretical sect also. They
would have said to Paul, ‘For concerning this heretical sect, it’s known
to us that it’s spoken against everywhere.’
The implication when
the word is used in this kind of negative context, implies that the translators
should have used, ‘heretical sect’, and not just ‘sect.’ This is also part
of the Greek word’s definition as both Perschbacher and Friberg bring out.
Perschbacher says that by implication, it can mean, ‘discord’ or ‘contention’.
And Friberg adds, ‘in a religious sense, of belief contrary to established
doctrine’, and therefore, ‘heresy’ or ‘false teaching’.(4) And when we
step back for a moment, and listen to how the Greek word sounds, hay-ray-see-ohs,
we can hear where we get our English word for ‘heresy.’
What we have in Scripture,
about our Jewish believing brethren is obvious to see. Peter and Paul were
called heretics by the ones who had a stranglehold on the established religion
of their day. Should we find it strange that we, both Jewish and Gentile
believers, are called heretics by the Church (for keeping His Torah)? You
may want to realize that as hard as you try to be model believers, most
will continue to think you’re part of a heretical cult (like the Mormons
or Jehovah Witnesses who also ‘claim Jesus’).
And we who are Jewish
believers, are also called heretics by our Jewish people and the supposed
democratic state of Israel which refuses Jewish believers Israeli citizenship.
They tell us that we are ‘not kosher Jews’. How a democratic state could
even go into the area of ‘orthodoxy’ is one giant problem. And for them
to go there and then to deny us citizenship because we say we’ve found
Messiah in Yeshua, is truly an example of the political situation here.
But the God of Israel has placed His Land in our hearts, and He has brought
us back home. He will also keep us here. Praise Yahveh! We’re in Good Company,
or should I say, God’s Company? : )
I’ve listed the six
places below so you can see them at a glance and determine for yourself
if ‘heretical sect’ should be in our English translations at Acts 24:5,
14 and 28:22.
The Three Places Where ‘Sect’ is
a Proper Translation
Acts 5:17: ‘But the
High Priest rose up, along with all his associates (that is the sect of
the Sadducees), and they were filled with jealousy.’
Acts 15:5: ‘But some
of the sect of the Pharisees who had believed stood up, saying, “It is
necessary to circumcise them and to direct them to observe the Law of Moses.”’
Acts 26:5: ‘since
they have known about me for a long time, if they are willing to testify,
that I lived as a Pharisee according to the strictest sect of our religion.’
The Three Places Where ‘Heretical
Sect’ is a Proper Translation
Acts 24:5: ‘For we
have found this man a real pest and a fellow who stirs up dissension among
all the Jews throughout the world, and a ringleader of the heretical sect
of the Nazarenes.’
Acts 24:14: ‘But this
I admit to you, that according to the Way which they call a heretical sect,
I do serve the God of our fathers, believing everything that is written
in the Law and the Prophets’.
Acts 28:22: ‘But we
desire to hear from you what your views are. For concerning this heretical
sect, it’s known to us that it is spoken against everywhere.’
1. I call him the
Turtle because his name in Greek is Ter-tu-los, which to me, sounds like ‘turtle.’ In
English it comes across as Tertullus, which in itself is close to turtle,
but the Greek really presents this ‘great orator’ as such. In Hebrew, this
orator is known as a ‘ba’al dih-var-reem’ (a master of words). That’s quite
a title for a turtle.
2. Wesley J. Perschbacher,
Editor, The New Analytical Greek Lexicon (Peabody, MA, USA: Hendrickson Publications,
1990), p. 9.
3. Timothy Friberg,
Barbara Friberg and Neva Miller, Analytical Lexicon of the Greek New Testament
(Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Books, 2000), p. 37.
Email Avram — firstname.lastname@example.org